Page 20 of 20 FirstFirst ... 10151617181920
Results 381 to 399 of 399

Thread: The Road to the 2019 Champion Hurdle

  1. #381
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    2,659
    Thanks
    20
    Thanked 123 Times in 101 Posts
    can't believe anyone thought there wasn't something amiss with Apple's Jade

  2. #382
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Posts
    7,310
    Thanks
    814
    Thanked 1,032 Times in 875 Posts
    If that's a pop at me, you can stow it, James.
    Apples Jade may well have scoped badly as the result of a hard race.
    Now, I'm quite capable of reading form, but replays don't show the inside of the mare's lungs, though they clearly showed her outpaced from a good way out. I'll take that evidence as read (not least because I'd predicted it twice before the race).If you wish to decipher the run differently, go ahead. I'll be there, taking her on every time she runs in similar circumstances.

  3. #383
    Senior Member Desert Orchid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    23,659
    Thanks
    2,930
    Thanked 3,482 Times in 2,742 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by reet hard View Post
    Apples Jade may well have scoped badly as the result of a hard race.
    I'd suggest she was beaten too far out for her to have had a hard race had she been 100% well in herself beforehand, physically and mentally.

    I'm disinclined to blame the track. Again, for me it was too far out for it to have been an issue.

    Maybe she just had an off day.

    The sectionals I measured for her in earlier runs point to her being vastly superior to Wicklow Brave who nearly won the Coral Cup under top weight. She was also vastly superior to Early Doors who won the Martin Pipe under top weight.

    I'm sure at some time in the future events will show that she would have won the race the other day regardless of how impressive the winner was.
    Last edited by Desert Orchid; 17th March 2019 at 9:01 AM.
    Illegitimi non carborundum


  4. #384
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Posts
    7,310
    Thanks
    814
    Thanked 1,032 Times in 875 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Desert Orchid View Post
    I'd suggest she was beaten too far out for her to have had a hard race had she been 100% well in herself beforehand, physically and mentally.

    I'm disinclined to blame the track. Again, for me it was too far out for it to have been an issue.

    Maybe she just had an off day.

    The sectionals I measured for her in earlier runs point to her being vastly superior to Wicklow Brave who nearly won the Coral Cup under top weight. She was also vastly superior to Early Doors who won the Martin Pipe under top weight.

    I'm sure at some time in the future events will show that she would have won the race the other day regardless of how impressive the winner was.
    So you could see inside her lungs, and thus knew exactly when her distress started? .Spare me, ffs.
    I've little time for NH sectionals, moreso those produced by a relative tyro, mostly on Irish courses, but here's what I'll do: a nifty for forum coffers if she ever wins proper 2m championship test, on anything bar heavy ground against CH horses.
    You might care to reciprocate when she doesn't.

  5. #385
    Senior Member Desert Orchid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    23,659
    Thanks
    2,930
    Thanked 3,482 Times in 2,742 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by reet hard View Post
    So you could see inside her lungs, and thus knew exactly when her distress started? .Spare me, ffs.
    That's an unfathomable comment. I'm not sure what kind of twisted logic could arrive at that interpretation of what I wrote.


    Quote Originally Posted by reet hard View Post
    I've little time for NH sectionals, moreso those produced by a relative tyro, mostly on Irish courses
    I presume the tyro remark is directed at me? Nearly everyone who does sectionals could be described as a "tyro" since the technology to produce them is only recent. Even Timeform gave up on them after a brief experimental period although Simon Rowlands has been doing a bit more on them lately. The ones I do are mainly for big race days here when the class of racing is sufficiently high to lend a degree of reliability to them. I only do Irish ones when there's serious racing on and I've never drawn strong conclusions from them, merely strong ideas.

    Define "proper 2m championship test, on anything bar heavy ground against CH horses", please? Are we talking one race per season? Talk about stacking the odds in your own favour. You should be a bookie.
    Illegitimi non carborundum


  6. #386
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Posts
    7,310
    Thanks
    814
    Thanked 1,032 Times in 875 Posts
    There is no 'technology' for furlong-by-furlong sectionals save those produced by ATR (which went out of the window for Irish racing when they jumped ship to RTV) or from Meydan and the odd tilt from Turftrax. Simon Rowlands is to be admired for struggling manfully on with his obstacle-to-obstacle 'sectonals' but even he's been known to blot his copybook occasionally (viz; turning the formbook on its head by claiming Hurricane Fly 'outstayed' the likes of Rock On Ruby and Zarkander in the 013 CH).

    No, not 1 race per season, neither the kind of races you appear to have used to justify your support for her as a future Champion Hurdler . Confess I haven't checked them all out, but I'm aware enough of her form to know she's never likely to be.

  7. #387
    Senior Member Desert Orchid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    23,659
    Thanks
    2,930
    Thanked 3,482 Times in 2,742 Posts
    Hopefully we can agree to just wait and see
    Illegitimi non carborundum


  8. #388
    Senior Member Desert Orchid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    23,659
    Thanks
    2,930
    Thanked 3,482 Times in 2,742 Posts
    For me, the key sentence from Simon Rowlands's sectional analysis:

    It is interesting to note that all of the first six in the Supreme would have finished ahead of the runner-up in the Champion in raw time terms.
    The sixth home in the supreme was Aramon, beaten 11¼ lengths.

    By the way, does anyone remember what price Douvan, Vautour and Champagne Fever were for the Champion Hurdle in the first few days after winning the Supreme?
    Last edited by Desert Orchid; 18th March 2019 at 1:38 PM.
    Illegitimi non carborundum


  9. #389
    Super Moderator Diamond Geezer's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Posts
    13,884
    Thanks
    2,576
    Thanked 4,128 Times in 2,052 Posts
    Marten Julian

    There are a couple of observations I would like to make now, starting with the first day. At this point in time, and unless I have reason to think otherwise, I would be very wary of taking the results at face value.
    I’m not sure how soft the ground was – it read 6 on the penetrometer and 6.7 by Friday – but the winning margins may, in my view, prove misleading.
    This applies specifically to the Champion Hurdle, which Espoir D’Allen won by 15 lengths – the widest margin of victory ever in the event. Earlier Duc Des Genievres won the Arkle Trophy by 13 lengths and later A Plus Tard took the Close Brothers Handicap by 16 lengths.
    It would be wrong to take anything away from these three winners, but I will be amazed if the form of any of the three races holds up to inspection in the fullness of time.
    On figures, assuming Melon ran to his mark of 165, Espoir D’Allen ran to a rating of 180, as opposed to his current figure of 162. This from a horse whose victories had been at Grade 3 level and had met his only defeat when tried at Grade 1 level last February.
    Willie Mullins said afterwards that Melon put up the best run of his life but the proximity of 156-rated Silver Streak in third must cast doubt on the value of the form. Then, of course, we have the efforts of the mares Laurina and Apple’s Jade, with the third-flight departure of Buveur d’Air , who brought down Sharjah.
    To say the race was ‘unsatisfactory’ is an understatement. The mares can be excused poor runs because they are mares, subject to physical changes from one day to the next, but it was hugely frustrating to lose the dual-Champion Hurdle and, to some extent, my each-way selection Sharjah.
    Regarding the wide winning margins of the three races I have mentioned, my view is that we were dealing with false ground. That it not to say the clerk and his team are in any way to blame, but that the heavy rain that fell in the hours before the meeting, following a sustained spell of dry ground in the weeks before, caused the going to ride loose on top.
    Put succinctly, some horses coped with it while others didn’t.
    The frustration didn’t end with the Champion Hurdle. It was disappointing to see Glen Forsa and Kalashnikov make early departures from the Arkle. The latter especially, probably would have relished the conditions. Almost half the field failed to complete in the Ultima Handicap Chase while Benie Des Dieux took that last-flight tumble in the Mares’ Hurdle. Sadly only four finished in the National Hunt Challenge Cup.
    Now don’t get me wrong. The meeting proved a success for my clients, with a profit made to level stakes and some good winners, but something strange was happening on the first day and my advice, again, is to be very guarded about taking the form too literally.
    Perhaps more will be revealed at Aintree.

  10. The Following 7 Users Say Thank You to Diamond Geezer For This Useful Post:

    2017diary (18th March 2019), Carl (19th March 2019), edgt (18th March 2019), jinnyj (18th March 2019), Outsider (18th March 2019), reet hard (19th March 2019), Tout Seul (19th March 2019)

  11. #390
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    North Cork. Home of steeple chasing
    Posts
    5,341
    Thanks
    2,209
    Thanked 1,335 Times in 801 Posts
    Blog Entries
    7
    art was out on course for Cross Country and was shocked at the state of the going at various points.
    Standing water, loose moving topsoil and ground cutting up badly were the order of the day.
    That the major rain fell so close to the meeting did not help what was undoubtedly the most difficult final four weeks pre racing the ground team had for many a year. The race results day 1 reflected that.
    Overnight drying with high winds made day 2 and later racing on days 3 and 4 a better spectacle though it seems a pity the new track crosses the old from final fence and hurdle to the line.
    this should be checked into and amended if possible methinks; it did Might Bite no favours last year and did not help a few last week either.

  12. #391
    Super Moderator Diamond Geezer's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Posts
    13,884
    Thanks
    2,576
    Thanked 4,128 Times in 2,052 Posts
    There was plenty of watering being done on the Cross Country course during the previous week

  13. #392
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Posts
    7,310
    Thanks
    814
    Thanked 1,032 Times in 875 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Diamond Geezer View Post
    Marten Julian

    There are a couple of observations I would like to make now, starting with the first day. At this point in time, and unless I have reason to think otherwise, I would be very wary of taking the results at face value.
    I’m not sure how soft the ground was – it read 6 on the penetrometer and 6.7 by Friday – but the winning margins may, in my view, prove misleading.
    This applies specifically to the Champion Hurdle, which Espoir D’Allen won by 15 lengths – the widest margin of victory ever in the event. Earlier Duc Des Genievres won the Arkle Trophy by 13 lengths and later A Plus Tard took the Close Brothers Handicap by 16 lengths.
    It would be wrong to take anything away from these three winners, but I will be amazed if the form of any of the three races holds up to inspection in the fullness of time.
    On figures, assuming Melon ran to his mark of 165, Espoir D’Allen ran to a rating of 180, as opposed to his current figure of 162. This from a horse whose victories had been at Grade 3 level and had met his only defeat when tried at Grade 1 level last February.
    Willie Mullins said afterwards that Melon put up the best run of his life but the proximity of 156-rated Silver Streak in third must cast doubt on the value of the form. Then, of course, we have the efforts of the mares Laurina and Apple’s Jade, with the third-flight departure of Buveur d’Air , who brought down Sharjah.
    To say the race was ‘unsatisfactory’ is an understatement. The mares can be excused poor runs because they are mares, subject to physical changes from one day to the next, but it was hugely frustrating to lose the dual-Champion Hurdle and, to some extent, my each-way selection Sharjah.
    Regarding the wide winning margins of the three races I have mentioned, my view is that we were dealing with false ground. That it not to say the clerk and his team are in any way to blame, but that the heavy rain that fell in the hours before the meeting, following a sustained spell of dry ground in the weeks before, caused the going to ride loose on top.
    Put succinctly, some horses coped with it while others didn’t.
    The frustration didn’t end with the Champion Hurdle. It was disappointing to see Glen Forsa and Kalashnikov make early departures from the Arkle. The latter especially, probably would have relished the conditions. Almost half the field failed to complete in the Ultima Handicap Chase while Benie Des Dieux took that last-flight tumble in the Mares’ Hurdle. Sadly only four finished in the National Hunt Challenge Cup.
    Now don’t get me wrong. The meeting proved a success for my clients, with a profit made to level stakes and some good winners, but something strange was happening on the first day and my advice, again, is to be very guarded about taking the form too literally.
    Perhaps more will be revealed at Aintree.
    Probably the most sensible synopsis of the Champion Hurdle result I've seen.
    Just watched the race back. it's not what it seems (imo) and, like so many wide margin soft ground winners, Esporie D'Allen appears overrated as a consequence.
    My view is they went off too quickly on the ground (It's noteworthy that Ruby, probably the best pace judge in the race, was having none of it on Laurina) causing Melon to be beaten a piece further than she was last year, with the 3rd horse doing the form no favours,at all.
    Imo, the winner has only shown his best 2m form on soft, looks bred for further, and will have difficulty repeating the form in the foreseeable future.

  14. #393
    Senior Member PlaceBacker's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Posts
    2,643
    Thanks
    428
    Thanked 317 Times in 260 Posts
    Apples Jade best form is in Ireland, so maybe she will not be using her passport again!
    "The wise man is one who knows what he does not know"

  15. #394
    Senior Member Desert Orchid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    23,659
    Thanks
    2,930
    Thanked 3,482 Times in 2,742 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by reet hard View Post
    Probably the most sensible synopsis of the Champion Hurdle result I've seen.
    Just watched the race back. it's not what it seems (imo) and, like so many wide margin soft ground winners, Esporie D'Allen appears overrated as a consequence.
    My view is they went off too quickly on the ground (It's noteworthy that Ruby, probably the best pace judge in the race, was having none of it on Laurina) causing Melon to be beaten a piece further than she was last year, with the 3rd horse doing the form no favours,at all.
    Imo, the winner has only shown his best 2m form on soft, looks bred for further, and will have difficulty repeating the form in the foreseeable future.
    I'm still working on my review but this is an extract:

    My conclusion is that the Champion Hurdle fell completely apart. Buveur D’Air tipped up and brought down Sharjah, Apple’s Jade was never going from at least the mistake at the second flight, Walsh said Laurina was never travelling, Verdana Blue couldn’t go in the ground, Brain Power was never really any better than last place before pulling up coming down the hill and Global Citizen ran no race either. Mark Walsh himself admitted after the race he was riding Espoir D’Allen for a place and Evan Williams said he felt he had no real hope of getting placed in the race with 80/1 shot Silver Streak.
    Illegitimi non carborundum


  16. #395
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    North Cork. Home of steeple chasing
    Posts
    5,341
    Thanks
    2,209
    Thanked 1,335 Times in 801 Posts
    Blog Entries
    7
    Having fallen Buveur D'Air got up , followed and nearly caught Espoir before running out at the last hurdle. That will to race attitude reminded me of the day un De Sceaux tipped up 2 out at Leopardstown yet ran on to pass the winner and runner up before the finish line. Buveur should not be underestimated by anyone should he meet Espoir again.

  17. The Following User Says Thank You to edgt For This Useful Post:

    Outsider (20th March 2019)

  18. #396
    Senior Member G-G's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Not got much to lose.
    Posts
    3,187
    Thanks
    726
    Thanked 471 Times in 295 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by PlaceBacker View Post
    Apples Jade best form is in Ireland, so maybe she will not be using her passport again!
    Maybe simplistically she didn't like being away from familiar surroundings? If she got herself in a tizz in the days before, would take it's toll. Not in the same class obviously but my mare used to get very unsettled if out of her usual surroundings and was a very stressy traveller.
    Vote Alfie!!!!

  19. #397
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Posts
    7,310
    Thanks
    814
    Thanked 1,032 Times in 875 Posts
    Still say Apples Jade went off too quickly - 4 secs faster than the Supreme to past the 3rd hdl, according to Simon Rowland's figures - and couldn't maintain that pace against proper 2m horses. She capitulated before the next hurdle, way before fitness should have become an issue.
    Last edited by reet hard; 21st March 2019 at 2:41 AM.

  20. #398
    Senior Member Desert Orchid's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    23,659
    Thanks
    2,930
    Thanked 3,482 Times in 2,742 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by PlaceBacker View Post
    Apples Jade best form is in Ireland, so maybe she will not be using her passport again!
    Her win at Aintree a couple of years ago was better than anything else she'd done until then but maybe as she's getting older she's becoming more of a home-lover.
    Illegitimi non carborundum


  21. #399
    Senior Member granger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Moscow Flyer Stables
    Posts
    18,886
    Thanks
    831
    Thanked 1,025 Times in 735 Posts
    Some people say he’s the best since Arkle and that’s certainly true when you look at what he’s done

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •